This is my favorite new show of the season. I have watched 2 so far and I have no idea what is going on! I like it! When the guy from the millenium show asked the kid if he "wanted to know a secret?" ....I nearly jumped out of bed! Can't wait to hear about the secret next week.
Mel

Might we all have to blame the Frenchies for the polar bears? My theory is there is (read: was) some sort of French research station on the other side of the island that was experimenting with the polar bears.
I really want to know what Kate's crime was. And what's up with the Asian couple. I'd also like them to find Vincent.
That message was just creepy! Repeating over and over like that....yeeks. Vincent is probably dogfood. Nah, I bet he surfaces 3 episodes from now as a hero. No no vincent .!.!. wasn't that what the asian couple was eating? raw dog? hehehe
Well, I for one would be eating that bear rather than the nasty labor inducing sushi.
That was the worst episode yet. I didn't care. Out of the blue, he becomes a turd? That so went against everything we liked about him it all felt contrived and stupid. I was actually twiddling my thumbs. Monsters! I want fighting! I want CrEePy messages! I want sex! I want monsters!
Oh, and if they gave away the premise like I think the did last night.....that writer should be shot! It was way too early to do so. That is something they should have "implied" in a finale or something, but not now. If I am right about where this is going, I won't be watching long.
Bummer
Mel
:P
Jack was getting crazier and crazier and I thought him running off was much needed. It was a very important episode in regards to filling people in and we needed to have an episode of bickering. However, this was the perfect oppurtunity for Claire to squeeze that damned kid out. Why couldn't we have gotten that over and done with then?
It wasn't a bad episode - merely an episode that is average compared to other shows out there. Lost usually spoils us. Anyways, we're getting to some good stuff next week if the teaser is any indication.
Maybe they'll hurry up and go looking for those damn Frenchies.
Clearly my least favorite episode. I'm thinking on this one they brought in the "B" team. I liked the mysticism and I liked the sightings of Jack's father and how that could push him over the edge. But the newbie written flashbacks with their on the nose dialog made my skin crawl. And clearly I'm not alone. This week was the first time the show lost ratings between the first and second half hour. Nothing wrong with challenging your lead actor, but if you're gonna do it then do it right.
And the biggest problem...and it's a huge one. Something was said during the episode that was supposed to be sly. A hint at what was really going on. And it was too much too early. Because Melanie guessed it. And I think she's right. If she's right then we shouldn't know this so early in the season...so early in the series. I hope she's wrong but it works perfectly.
Although yes, I think next week looks good.
Clearly my least favorite episode. I'm thinking on this one they brought in the "B" team. I liked the mysticism and I liked the sightings of Jack's father and how that could push him over the edge. But the newbie written flashbacks with their on the nose dialog made my skin crawl. And clearly I'm not alone. This week was the first time the show lost ratings between the first and second half hour. Nothing wrong with challenging your lead actor, but if you're gonna do it then do it right.
8D Thats the way it is done do you not think so.